Thursday, July 17, 2008

Yet another sad tale of misunderstanding

You can just read this article on the BBC about the Dongria people in India being pushed off their land (unless the supreme court of India prevents it, which they might!) for development. But first let me sum up: Vedanta mining company has already taken some land and kicked off the people living there (which raises the question about land rights... if you and your ancestors have been living on a land longer than any government has existed but never wanted, needed, or taken legal right to the land, how can any one else claim the land? but they can! and they do all the time!!!) and now they want to mine the sacred mountain of the Dongria people.

Vedanta claims:
"They will be there where they are today. The only thing is that if that area develops they will get better living conditions, because we may develop some roads, some better infrastructure, better communications, better living conditions."

But here's the misunderstanding that leads to almost every one of these confrontations! "Better living conditions" means something different to every people and person, so who are they to say a road into their land is better or worse? Just as our pristine wild lands are disappearing to development, so are our pristine cultures. And I believe they deserve just as much protection as the land and animals we work so hard to save.

No comments: